PGA Tour Confidential: The Big Three, The Big Story and the Big Winners of 2014

Tiger Woods, Phil Mickelson, Rory McIlroy
Getty Images
Tiger Woods and Phil Mickelson will look for continued success in 2014, while Rory McIlroy will try to put a dismal 2013 behind him.

1. Who's going to have the best 2014 of the Big Three -- Tiger, Phil or Rory?

John Garrity, contributing writer, Sports Illustrated (@jgarrity2): I expect McIlroy to reassert himself and deliver the kind of dominating performance that you guys wrongly predicted for him in 2013. I'm the one who pointed out that he had made abrupt changes in virtually every aspect of his life -- equipment, management, continent, residence, you name it -- and he'd need at least a year to deal with all that. Well, he's had his year, and now he can concentrate on what's important -- golf and suing his management team.

Alan Shipnuck, senior writer, Sports Illustrated (@AlanShipnuck): His win in Australia was massive -- for him and the game. It makes 2014 much more intriguing.

Anonymous Tour pro: I think Rory wins a couple of Tour events but not a major. He's still figuring out his equipment to some degree.

Gary Van Sickle, senior writer, Sports Illustrated (@GaryVanSickle): It's human nature to get complacent after remarkable success and/or riches, and to forget that what got you there was long-term hard work. Ultimately, 2013 will be the best thing that ever happened to Rory.

ANONYMOUS PRO: I'm less optimistic about Phil. His window to play well gets smaller each year because, arthritis or no arthritis, guys in their 40s can't count on feeling that great four days in a row. Phil's swing is catching up with him because his body doesn't cooperate as well. Week in and week out, he can't be as sharp as he used to be. Now his bad weeks are bad.

Michael Bamberger, senior writer, Sports Illustrated: We all know Phil is going to win the U.S. Open. That'll be enough.

VAN SICKLE: Does it worry you that Phil always played his way into form by teeing it up three, four or five weeks in a row, and now he's cutting back?

SHIPNUCK: He said he's going to reduce his schedule after the PGA Championship, so the FedEx Cup playoffs may go on without him. Look, this is a one-tournament season for Phil. If he wins the U.S Open, it'll be a spectacular year.

ANONYMOUS PRO: Of the three, next year is the biggest for Tiger. If he doesn't win any majors, his race to catch Jack is over.

BAMBERGER: Tiger is the most poised to have a big year. There's been something missing in his majors play. He's shown over a lot of years that he's very smart. He'll figure out the problem.

VAN SICKLE: What if he decides the problem is his teacher, Sean Foley?

BAMBERGER: Foley isn't the problem. Tiger won five tourneys against tough fields on difficult courses. It's a mental hurdle for Tiger.

SHIPNUCK: Tiger's swing isn't the issue. He gets on the green and looks spooked at times. It's not so easy to fix that.

ANONYMOUS PRO: Tiger has gone off the deep end on his weightlifting workouts again. He made some swings in Turkey that were so short and flat because he can barely get his arms above his muscle-bound shoulders. He's lost his old suppleness and seems to be trying to regain his speed by being strong. His body doesn't look like a golfer's body anymore, the way it did from 1996 until about 2007.

SHIPNUCK: The things that used to separate Tiger were his head, his putting and the ability to summon the shot that's called for. Now that's all in question. It's a fascinating flip. If he can't get it done this year, I don't know if he can get to 15 majors, let alone 19.

VAN SICKLE: Tiger's swing looks suspiciously like stack and tilt. He isn't getting it done in majors for the same reason the other stack-and-tilt guys haven't: the driver. Under pressure, you can't trap the ball with a driver with any consistency.

SHIPNUCK: The most shocking swing of the year was Tiger's at number 13 at Augusta on Sunday. He played a cut over the trees! If there's any hole in golf where you need to play a draw, it's 13. That shot revealed something. You can't blame it all on the putter like Tiger tries to do.

2. What will be golf's big story in 2014?

ANONYMOUS PRO: I wouldn't be surprised if Tiger and Foley part ways. I'm not sure Tiger has bought into everything Foley is telling him. Tiger's ego may be getting in the way too.

GARRITY: Tiger is way too far down the road to switch coaches again. He'd be better off with a performance coach. Anybody who watches Tiger practice knows that he hits it great on the range. He just has trouble taking it to the course.

VAN SICKLE: One thing we learned from Hank Haney's book is that Tiger is a surprisingly needy student.

GARRITY: Tiger's narcissism is at the root of his troubles. He could have quit tinkering during his Butch Harmon phase, because he had all the shots. Tiger could change trajectory at will, shape shots however he wanted, hit every conceivable pitch and chip, hit it from rough, sand, water and oatmeal, if necessary. That's all a golfer can do. But every now and then Tiger hit a bad shot, and he couldn't accept that. Now he no longer has all the shots.

VAN SICKLE: Vijay Singh's lawsuit against the PGA Tour about his use of deer-antler spray could have legs. His attorney has alleged that other Tour drug-policy violators have gotten exemptions and special treatment. Some Tour secrets may get spilled in court.

BAMBERGER: What does Vijay want? If he's looking for a payday, he's going to get it. If he's looking to embarrass the Tour, it could get interesting.

SHIPNUCK: It sounds like a vendetta. The Tour has besmirched him in the twilight of his career. It's not about money -- he wants to destroy Tim Finchem and the Tour. It's going to be really, really ugly, and I'm really, really excited about it.

BAMBERGER: Actually, I think it could be about the money. The payday could be staggering.

GARRITY: Yes, but Vijay can't claim Finchem damaged his reputation without opening himself up to questions about his reputation, which means reviving that old Asian-tour suspension for alleged cheating and some long-forgotten tangles with Australian golf authorities. Vijay can't go there.

SHIPNUCK: All this off-course stuff in golf -- the anchoring ban, the drug testing, it's all just something to talk about in December. Ultimately, it comes down to who wins where. A year is always remembered for its champions. Like Adam Scott at the Masters and Phil at the British.

VAN SICKLE: Which would be a bigger story, Tiger winning a major or Phil finally winning his elusive U.S. Open?

SHIPNUCK: Phil's quest has become so big that even non-golf fans know about it. Even if you weren't a football fan, you knew about Peyton Manning's quest to win a Super Bowl ring. It transcends the sport.

BAMBERGER: Tiger winning any major is bigger. It gets him to 15 and, most important, reopens the chase to 18.

GARRITY: Phil's Open would be bigger because the career Grand Slam would complete that story arc.

SHIPNUCK: Tiger winning a Masters would be the most impactful, to use Finchem's favorite word.

Forecast
PGA Tour News
Trips
Travel & Courses
Lessons
Tips & Videos
The Shop
Equipment News & Reviews