1975
Jack Nicklaus vs. Tom Weiskopf
276-277

Already a three-time Masters runner-up, Tom Weiskopf stood on the 16th tee, watching his old rival Nicklaus staring down a tough 40-foot putt on the green. Johnny Miller had thrown a late charge into the proceedings, but Weiskopf had snagged a one-shot lead after birdies at 14 and 15. Alas, Weiskopf's time would never come. The Golden Bear drained his massive uphill putt and celebrated by thrusting his putter toward the heavens. Drained, Weiskopf hit a fat 5-iron that left him 80 feet away. He three-putted, then barely missed a putt to tie on the final green.